Three plugins run SEO on most WordPress sites — Rank Math, Yoast SEO, and All in One SEO — and the price that decides between them is not the price on the pricing page. It is the renewal price, the per-site multiplier, and the feature that is free in one plugin and paid in another. Rank Math PRO renews at $107.88 a year for unlimited personal websites; Yoast Premium costs $99 a year per site; AIOSEO Basic costs $49.50 in year one and renews at $99. One site costs nearly the same for all three over three years; 25 sites cost $323.64, $1,797, or $7,425. The plugin is the same job; the license model is the whole decision.
This guide prices the three from the vendors' own pricing pages, read November 18, 2026, on the same three profiles — 1, 5, and 25 sites — at renewal prices over three years. Renewal prices are the steady-state cost: Rank Math's first-year prices are promotional, AIOSEO's renewal runs roughly double the first year, and Yoast charges full price from year one. Every total in this guide uses the renewal price.
Who this guide is for, and who should stop here
This guide is for a WordPress site owner choosing an SEO plugin — blogger, small business, agency — who wants the annual cost at their real site count, not the headline price, and wants to know which ceiling hits first: the site count, the keyphrase limit, or the rank tracker.
Stop here if the site is not WordPress: none of these three plugins runs anywhere else. Stop here if the decision is the CMS itself rather than the plugin — see the Webflow vs Framer vs WordPress pricing guide and the headless WordPress decoupling playbook. Stop here if the site needs enterprise SEO tooling — crawl budgets, log analysis, multi-market hreflang — because no WordPress plugin is that tool. If the site is headless WordPress, note that all three plugins assume a coupled admin for their settings screens.
The three free tiers
All three have a genuinely free tier, and for a single small site it may be the whole answer. The free tiers differ where it matters: focus keyphrases per post, the redirect manager, and rank tracking.
| Free-tier feature | Rank Math Free | Yoast SEO Free | AIOSEO Lite |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus keyphrases per post | Unlimited keyword optimization | 1 | TruSEO, up to 10 keywords |
| Redirect manager | Included | Premium only | Paid tiers |
| Rank tracking | PRO feature | Premium only | Top tier only |
| Schema markup | 840+ schema types | Schema graph output | Smart Schema |
The redirect manager is the sharpest free-tier difference. Rank Math ships it free; Yoast holds it for Premium; AIOSEO holds it for paid tiers. A site that migrates URLs or deletes posts needs redirects from day one, and the plugin that charges for them adds $99 a year to a job the free competitor does. The keyphrase limit is the second difference: Yoast Free allows one focus keyphrase per post, while Rank Math's free tier allows unlimited keyword optimization and AIOSEO's free tier tracks up to 10 additional TruSEO keywords.
The price cards: renewal is the real price
| Vendor | Plan | First year | Renewal (per year) | Sites |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rank Math | PRO | $59.88 promo observed | $107.88 | Unlimited personal |
| Rank Math | Business | $179.88–$251.88 promo variants | $335.88 | Unlimited personal |
| Rank Math | Agency | $395.88–$563.88 promo variants | $779.88 | 500+ client websites |
| Yoast | Premium | $99 | $99 | 1 |
| Yoast | Premium Plus | $229 | $229 | 1, add-ons included |
| AIOSEO | Basic | $49.50 | $99 | 1 |
| AIOSEO | Plus | $99.50 | $199 | 3 |
| AIOSEO | Pro | $199.50 | $399 | 10 |
| AIOSEO | Elite | $299.50 | $599 | 100 |
Rank Math's comparison table: PRO stays flat while Yoast scales per site.
Three facts in that table decide most purchases. First, Rank Math's first-year prices are promotional: the page's FAQ states the renewals — PRO $107.88, Business $335.88, Agency $779.88 per year — and first-year figures vary by coupon, with $59.88 observed for PRO during the Black Friday promotion. Second, AIOSEO's renewal is roughly double its first-year price on all four tiers — $49.50 to $99, $99.50 to $199, $199.50 to $399, $299.50 to $599 — so a buyer who budgets the first-year price is budgeting half the real cost. Third, Yoast has no first-year discount and no renewal increase: Premium is $99 a year, every year, per site. Yoast's pricing page does not render from this network, so the $99 figure is corroborated across independent 2026 reviews.
Rank Math PRO carries one restriction that matters more than its price: unlimited personal websites, client websites excluded. An agency running client sites on PRO is outside the license; the Agency tier at $779.88 a year is the compliant answer. AIOSEO has no personal-versus-client distinction. Yoast Premium is one site, period; multi-site bundles are a custom quote.
Worked math: 1, 5, and 25 sites over three years
Example: three owners at renewal prices for three years — one blog, five niche sites, an agency with 25 client sites:
At one site, the three are within $27 of each other over three years: Rank Math PRO $323.64, Yoast Premium $297, AIOSEO Basic $297 at renewal. Year one flatters AIOSEO and Rank Math, but by year two the renewals have converged.
At five sites, the models diverge. Rank Math PRO still costs $323.64 — one license covers unlimited personal websites. Yoast Premium costs 5 × $99 × 3 years, or $1,485. AIOSEO needs the Pro tier — 10 sites at $399 renewal — for $1,197, because Plus covers only 3 sites. The five-site Yoast buyer pays 4.6 times the Rank Math PRO price.
At 25 sites, the gap becomes the decision. Rank Math PRO is $323.64 for a personal portfolio, Agency $2,339.64 for client sites. AIOSEO Elite, at $599 renewal for 100 sites, is $1,797. Yoast Premium is 25 × $99 × 3 years, or $7,425 — 22.9 times the Rank Math PRO price:
| Profile | Rank Math | Yoast | AIOSEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 site, 3 years | PRO $323.64 | $297 | Basic $297 |
| 5 sites, 3 years | PRO $323.64 | $1,485 | Pro $1,197 |
| 25 sites, 3 years | PRO $323.64 / Agency $2,339.64 | $7,425 | Elite $1,797 |
AIOSEO pricing page: first-year prices and site counts.
Unit economics: cost per site, cost per tracked keyword
Cost per site at renewal: AIOSEO Basic $99, Plus $199 over 3 sites ($66.33 each), Pro $399 over 10 ($39.90), Elite $599 over 100 ($5.99). Yoast Premium is $99 per site at every count, because the license does not scale. Rank Math PRO is $107.88 for the first site and $0 for every site after it.
Cost per tracked keyword: Rank Math PRO tracks 1,000 keywords at $107.88 a year ($0.108 each), Business 20,000 at $335.88 ($0.017), Agency 75,000 at $779.88 ($0.010). The tracker gets cheaper per keyword as the tier rises — the opposite of the site license, which is cheapest at the bottom tier. An owner tracking 50 keywords uses 5 percent of the PRO meter; an agency tracking 60,000 uses 80 percent of the Agency meter. Buy the tier whose meter you will actually fill.
Feature ceilings that decide the buy
Price decides the license; ceilings decide whether the license does the job.
| Ceiling | Rank Math | Yoast | AIOSEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus keyphrases, free | Unlimited keyword optimization | 1 per post | TruSEO, up to 10 additional keywords |
| Focus keyphrases, paid | Unlimited | Up to 5 + synonyms | Up to 10 TruSEO keywords |
| Redirect manager | Free | Premium only | Paid tiers |
| Rank tracking | PRO 1,000; Business 20,000; Agency 75,000 | Premium + Semrush | Top tier only |
| AI content help | Content AI sold separately | AI title and description suggestions in Premium | Plus: 25,000 AI Credits |
| Internal linking suggestions | AI Link Genius | Premium | Link Assistant (Pro+) |
Three ceilings deserve a closer look. First, the keyphrase limit: Yoast Premium allows up to 5 focus keyphrases with synonyms, Rank Math allows unlimited keyword optimization on every tier, and AIOSEO tracks up to 10 additional TruSEO keywords on every paid tier. A team optimizing for a primary plus two secondaries needs the paid tier in Yoast and AIOSEO, and no paid tier in Rank Math. Second, the AI credits: AIOSEO Plus includes 25,000 AI Credits, Rank Math's Content AI is a separate credit product with Starter, Creator, and Expert tiers, and Yoast Premium bundles AI title and description suggestions with no separate meter. Third, the redirect manager: free in Rank Math, Premium-only in Yoast, a paid feature in AIOSEO. Count your redirects before you count your dollars.
The Yoast add-on trap
Yoast Premium is $99 a year, but Premium is not the whole product. Local SEO, Video SEO, News SEO, and WooCommerce SEO are separate add-ons at $79 a year each. A WooCommerce store that also wants local search pays $99 + $79 + $79, or $257 a year. All four add-ons plus Premium cost $415 a year:
Premium Plus is $229 a year for one site with all add-ons included — the store that needs all four saves $186 a year:
The trap is buying add-ons one at a time. Two add-ons cost $257 a year, already $28 over Premium Plus, and a third means paying for the bundle without owning it. Rank Math and AIOSEO bundle their equivalents — local SEO, WooCommerce SEO, video sitemaps — into the plugin tiers, so the add-on arithmetic does not exist for them. A WooCommerce store with a physical location is where Yoast's $99 headline misleads most, and Premium Plus is the only Yoast price worth comparing.
What goes wrong
Three failure modes dominate. First, the renewal shock: AIOSEO's first-year price is half its renewal, and Rank Math's first-year price is a promotion. A buyer who budgets $49.50 and $59.88 has budgeted year one; year two is $99 and $107.88. Budget the renewal price from day one. Second, the license breach: Rank Math PRO covers unlimited personal websites and excludes client websites. An agency that installs PRO on 25 client sites is outside the license; the fix is the Agency tier at $779.88 a year, or a different plugin. Third, migration: switching plugins is not free. Titles, descriptions, schema, and redirects live in the plugin's data, and the migration tools move most of it but not all of it. A site with 500 posts should price a half-day of cleanup into any switch and test it on staging first. Run the website cost calculator on the full stack before choosing — the plugin is the cheapest line in the stack, and the wrong one costs a day.
Execution checklist
- [x] Step 1: Count the sites. List every site, personal and client — Rank Math PRO excludes client sites, and the count decides the tier.
- [x] Step 2: Count the keyphrases. Record how many focus keyphrases each post needs: Yoast Free one, Premium five, Rank Math unlimited.
- [x] Step 3: Price the renewal, not the promotion. Use Rank Math PRO $107.88, AIOSEO Basic $99, Yoast Premium $99 a year; multiply by sites and by three years.
- [x] Step 4: Count the add-ons. List the Yoast add-ons at $79 each; if the total exceeds $229, buy Premium Plus instead.
- [x] Step 5: Test the free tier first. Install the free version, configure titles, descriptions, sitemaps, and schema, and check the redirect manager before paying.
- [x] Step 6: Test the migration on staging. If switching, run the migration on staging and verify titles, descriptions, schema, and redirects before touching production.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
The three plugins do the same job with three different meters. Rank Math sells unlimited personal sites and a tracker that gets cheaper per keyword as the tier rises. Yoast sells one site at a time at a flat $99, with add-ons that turn $99 into $415. AIOSEO sells a ladder from $49.50 to $599 where the renewal doubles the first year and the per-site cost falls to $5.99. Count the sites, count the keyphrases, price the renewal over three years — and the cheapest plugin picks itself. The rendering side is in the technical SEO for decoupled web apps guide.

