Sell one Gildan 5000 tee for $24.99 and three companies send three different bills. Printful charges $9.44 for the shirt plus $4.95 shipping and a $0.40 surcharge — $14.79 landed, $10.20 profit. Printify's cheapest catalog route is $8.55 plus $3.99 shipping — $12.54 landed, $12.45 profit. Gelato's own published example is $8.14 plus $4.66 economy shipping — $12.80 landed, $12.19 profit. The same shirt, the same retail price, a $2.25 profit spread before any subscription.
Three different businesses wearing one label
Printful owns its factories and lists one price per product — $9.44 for a Gildan 5000, $9.63 for a Gildan 64000, $11.92 for a Bella+Canvas 3001 — with shipping at a flat published rate. Printify owns no factories: a marketplace of more than 70 independent print providers, each setting its own price and shipping, so the catalog price is a "from" figure that depends on the provider. Gelato is a curated network: more than 140 print partners in 32 countries, each order routed to the facility nearest the buyer, and roughly 95 percent of orders produced in the country they ship to.
The model decides what can go wrong. With Printful, quality and delivery time are one company's responsibility. With Printify, the provider you pick decides both — the same design can cost $8.55 from one provider and $9.68 from Printify Choice, its own default routing, with different shipping and production times. With Gelato, you do not pick the facility at all: the network routes the order, so the same tee can come from different producers with slightly different color or placement. Delivery: Gelato quotes 2 to 4 days domestic and 4 to 6 days international; Printful 2 to 5 business days to produce plus shipping; Printify providers 2 to 5 days to produce.
The plan ladder, from the vendors' own pricing pages
| Plan | Monthly fee | What the fee buys | Authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Printful Free | $0 | Full catalog, pay per order | printful.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Printful Growth | $24.99/mo | Up to 33% off products; free 12 months at $12,000/yr sales | printful.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Printful Enterprise | Custom | Volume pricing | printful.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Printify Free | $0 | 5 store connections, unlimited designs, pay per order | printify.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Printify Premium | $39/mo, or $24.99/mo billed yearly ($299/yr) | Up to 20% off most products | printify.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Printify Enterprise | Custom | Volume pricing | printify.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Gelato Free | $0 | Full catalog, pay per order, no product discounts | gelato.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Gelato+ | $29.99/mo, or $19.99/mo billed yearly ($239.88/yr) | Up to 33% off products, Magic Mockups, Price Navigator | gelato.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
| Gelato Platinum | Custom | Volume pricing | gelato.com/pricing (Nov 18) |
Three facts matter more than the fees: every subscription discounts the product only, never shipping; every discount is stated as "up to", so the ceiling is not the discount on your product; and Printful Growth becomes free for 12 months at $12,000 a year in sales — the only paid plan that turns itself off at volume.
Worked math 1: one Gildan 5000 at $24.99 retail
Example: one unisex Gildan 5000, single front print, size M, shipped to a U.S. address, sold for $24.99 with free shipping to the buyer. Landed cost is the product plus the shipping on that order; profit is the retail price minus the landed cost.
Printful, Free plan: the catalog lists the Gildan 5000 at $9.44, shipping for shirts to the U.S. is $4.95 for the first item, plus a $0.40 surcharge on U.S. orders from October 15, 2026 to January 17, 2027:
Printify, Free plan: the catalog lists the Gildan 5000 from $8.55, and the cheapest quoted shipping on its Choice routing is $3.99:
Gelato, Free plan: Gelato's one published example is a Gildan 5000 shipped inside the U.S. at $8.14 plus $4.66 economy shipping:
On the free plans, Printify keeps $2.25 more per shirt than Printful, and Gelato keeps $1.99 more. The gap is shipping as much as product: Printful's $5.35 all-in shipping is the highest of the three. Note the Printify figure is a floor, not a promise: the $8.55 is the cheapest provider's price, and a different provider can raise it to $9.68 on Printify Choice.
Worked math 2: when the subscription pays for itself
A subscription pays only when the extra profit per shirt, times the shirts sold that month, exceeds the monthly fee. The extra profit is the discount on the product — shipping never changes.
Printful Growth at the 33 percent ceiling: the Gildan 5000 base falls from $9.44 to $6.32, the landed cost to $11.67, and the profit rises to $13.32 — $3.12 more per shirt. The break-even is the fee divided by the extra profit:
Printify Premium: the Gildan 5000 falls from $8.55 to $6.33, landed cost to $10.32, and the profit rises to $14.67 — $2.22 more per shirt. On monthly billing the break-even is $39.00 ÷ $2.22 = 17.6, or 18 shirts a month; on annual billing $24.99 ÷ $2.22 = 11.3, or 12 shirts a month.
Gelato+ at the 33 percent ceiling: the Gildan 5000 falls from $8.14 to $5.45, saving $2.69 a shirt. On monthly billing the break-even is $29.99 ÷ $2.69 = 11.1, or 12 shirts a month; on annual billing $19.99 ÷ $2.69 = 7.4, or 8 shirts a month. On product spend, Gelato+ breaks even at $90.88 a month on monthly billing and $60.58 on annual billing.
Two warnings: every break-even above assumes the full ceiling discount on every shirt, and a lower actual discount pushes every break-even up by roughly a third; and Gelato+'s 14-day trial unlocks the tools but not the product discount.
The 100-shirt month: what volume actually buys
| Plan | Landed cost per shirt | Profit per shirt | 100 shirts, after the fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Printful Free | $14.79 | $10.20 | $1,020.00 |
| Printful Growth | $11.67 | $13.32 | $1,307.01 |
| Printify Free | $12.54 | $12.45 | $1,245.00 |
| Printify Premium, annual | $10.32 | $14.67 | $1,442.01 |
| Gelato Free | $12.80 | $12.19 | $1,219.00 |
| Gelato+ annual | $10.11 | $14.88 | $1,468.01 |
At 100 shirts a month the paid plans are worth $225 to $287 over the free plans, and Gelato+ on annual billing edges Printify Premium by $26.00. At 10 shirts a month the ranking reverses: Printify Free keeps $124.50, Printify Premium on monthly billing keeps $107.70 after its $39 fee. The subscription decision is a volume decision.
The business footing: entity, tax, and the costs after the print bill
A print-on-demand store is a business, and the print bill is only the first cost. Run it as an LLC — an S-Corp election at scale, a C-Corp only with outside investors — with an EIN on the store and a CPA reviewing the first year's return. Under GAAP there is no inventory on the balance sheet: the blank and the print are COGS recognized at the sale, not when the design is uploaded. The owner's income is subject to SECA self-employment tax on net earnings, not FICA withholding. EU sales add VAT handling — Gelato collects local VAT on its orders, and on Etsy the marketplace facilitator rules make the platform the collector. All three expose an API and plug into Shopify and Etsy; a POS sale at a market stall routes to the same fulfillment as an online order.
The second-order costs decide whether the $12.45 Printify margin survives the storefront. On Etsy, a $24.99 sale pays a $0.20 listing fee, 6.5 percent transaction fee, and 3 percent plus $0.25 payment processing — $2.82 in total — because the fee base is the whole order. On a Shopify store the card processing is 2.9 percent plus $0.30, or $1.02 on $24.99. Add a returns reserve for misprints and wrong sizes, and the risk that a provider raises its price or drops a blank. We did not place test orders with any of the three platforms, so this guide makes no claim about print quality or delivery times beyond what the vendors state.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
What each platform is actually for
Printful is for the seller who wants one throat to choke: one company printing, fulfilling, and shipping, with a flat published shipping rate and in-house quality control, at the highest per-shirt landed cost of the three. Its catalog runs to more than 300 products, strongest in apparel and embroidery. Printify is for the seller who wants the widest choice and the lowest floor: more than 2,000 products across 70-plus providers, and the cheapest Gildan 5000 here — at the cost of vetting the provider on every product. Gelato is for the seller whose buyers are in many countries: 140-plus partners in 32 countries, roughly 95 percent of orders produced in the destination country, and the strongest wall-art catalog.
The catalog gap is the decision most sellers skip. Gelato's wall art has no equivalent at Printful; Printify's 2,000-product catalog has no equivalent at Gelato's roughly 250. A seller of framed posters who picks Printful for its factories has picked a platform whose strength is apparel. The Shopify versus WooCommerce versus BigCommerce playbook prices the storefront these products sell through, and the Paddle versus Lemon Squeezy versus Gumroad playbook prices the checkout that collects the money.
Shipping, returns, and the costs after the sale
Printful publishes flat rates — $4.95 for the first shirt to the U.S., $2.20 for each additional — so per-shirt shipping falls as the order grows. Printify's shipping is set by the provider, so the same shirt can ship for $3.99 from one provider and $4.95 from another. Gelato quotes shipping live per order; international orders are usually produced locally, so the shipping is short but the product price varies by country.
Returns follow the same split. A misprint or damaged item is reprinted or refunded by the platform that made it — Printful from its own factory, Printify through the provider, Gelato through the partner that produced the order, with 30 days after delivery to report a defect with a photo. A wrong size or a change of mind is the seller's problem on all three: the return shipping and remake come out of the seller's margin.
Execution checklist
- [x] Step 1 — Pick the anchor product and the destination: one blank, one print area, one buyer country.
- [x] Step 2 — Read the landed cost, not the base price: product plus shipping plus surcharge, from the vendor's own pages.
- [x] Step 3 — Compute the subscription break-even in shirts: fee divided by extra profit per shirt.
- [x] Step 4 — Check the catalog for your real products: wall art belongs on Gelato, the widest choice is on Printify, apparel is on Printful.
- [x] Step 5 — Test one order before listing fifty products: order the anchor product yourself and confirm the print, the size, and the delivery time.
- [x] Step 6 — Set the retail price from the landed cost: retail minus landed cost is the margin; if it is under 40 percent, raise the price or change the blank.
Who should not use each one
Do not choose Printful if your buyers are mostly outside the U.S. and your margin cannot carry $4.95-plus shipping on every shirt. Do not choose Printify if you will not vet providers: the cheapest price on the page is a different factory from the one you used last month. Do not choose Gelato if you need the same facility to print every order — the network routes each order to the nearest partner. And do not choose any of them if you sell physical goods at scale with your own inventory: at real volume the warehouse wins.

