When a foreign person sells U.S. real property, the tax does not wait for the seller's return. It is collected at the closing table, from the buyer, on the gross price — not the gain. IRC § 1445(a) requires the transferee to "deduct and withhold a tax equal to 15 percent of the amount realized on the disposition." The seller's actual tax bill is irrelevant: a seller owing $90,000 can still have $202,500 withheld, and the $112,500 difference sits with the IRS until a return is filed. The buyer is the withholding agent; if the buyer fails to withhold, the buyer is personally liable for the tax plus penalties and interest.
That inversion — buyer as collector, gross price as the base — is what makes FIRPTA the most expensive surprise in cross-border real estate. The seller is leaving the jurisdiction, so Congress put the collection duty on the party who stays.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
What counts as a U.S. real property interest
IRC § 897 taxes a foreign person's gain from a U.S. real property interest (USRPI) as if effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business — § 871(b)(1) for a nonresident alien, § 882(a)(1) for a foreign corporation — and § 1445 is the collection mechanism.
| Interest | USRPI? | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Fee ownership, co-ownership, leasehold, or an option to acquire U.S. land, improvements, or a leasehold | Yes | § 897(c)(1)(A), (c)(6)(A) |
| Associated personal property (movable walls, furnishings, farm machinery) | Yes | § 897(c)(6)(B) |
| Stock in a domestic USRPHC | Yes, if the 50% test is met | § 897(c)(1)(A)(ii), (c)(2) |
| Stock in a domestic corporation, where no class is publicly traded and the corporation was never a USRPHC during the holding period or the 5-year testing period | No | § 897(c)(1)(B) |
| Stock of a publicly traded corporation, held at 5% or less during the testing period | No | § 897(c)(3) |
| Interest in a domestically controlled QIE (REIT or RIC, under 50% foreign-owned) | No | § 897(h)(2), (h)(4)(B) |
| A mere creditor interest in real property | No | § 897(c)(1)(A) |
The USRPHC test is a balance-sheet ratio: a corporation is a USRPHC if the fair market value of its U.S. real property interests is at least 50 percent of the combined value of its U.S. real property interests, its foreign real property, and its other trade-or-business assets, measured over the shorter of the holding period or the 5 years ending on the disposition date. A corporation that sold all its U.S. property in fully taxable transactions during that window, or held none on the disposition date, is not a USRPHC — and after December 17, 2015, neither the corporation nor any predecessor may have been a RIC or a REIT during the testing period.
Worked example: a $1,350,000 sale, $202,500 withheld, $90,000 of tax
Take a foreign individual selling a Miami rental for $1,200,000 cash, the buyer assuming the seller's $150,000 mortgage, basis $900,000. The amount realized is not the cash alone — the IRS counts cash paid (principal only), the fair market value of other property, and any liability the buyer assumes:
The seller's gain is $450,000; at a 20 percent long-term capital gain rate the tax is $90,000. The withholding exceeds the tax by $112,500 — money the seller recovers only by filing a U.S. return (Form 1040-NR for an individual) with the stamped copy B of Form 8288-A attached. That over-withholding is normal: the statute withholds on price because price is knowable at closing and gain is not. Before February 17, 2016 the rate was 10 percent — $135,000 on the same sale — so a buyer who prices on the old rate under-withholds by a third and owes the difference personally.
The exceptions that actually excuse withholding
Section 1445(b) lists the exits. None is automatic — each needs a document in hand before the money moves, and a buyer relying on a false affidavit loses the protection.
| Exception | What the buyer needs | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Transferor furnishes a nonforeign affidavit | Affidavit under penalty of perjury with the transferor's U.S. TIN, stating the transferor is not a foreign person | § 1445(b)(2) |
| Nonpublicly traded domestic corporation certifies its stock is not a USRPI | Corporation's affidavit under penalty of perjury, dated within 30 days before transfer | § 1445(b)(3); IRS exceptions page |
| Transferee receives a qualifying statement from the IRS | Statement that the transferor agreed to pay the tax or is exempt, and the liability is satisfied or secured | § 1445(b)(4) |
| Residence where the amount realized does not exceed $300,000 | Buyer is an individual acquiring the property for use as a residence | § 1445(b)(5) |
| Stock regularly traded on an established securities market | The class of stock is publicly traded | § 1445(b)(6) |
| Withholding certificate from the IRS | Form 8288-B certificate excusing or reducing withholding | § 1445(c)(2); IRS exceptions page |
| Nonrecognition transfer (like-kind exchange, treaty provision) | Written notice meeting the five requirements of Treas. Reg. § 1.1445-2(d)(2)(iii); transferee files a copy by the 20th day after transfer | IRS exceptions page |
| Amount realized is zero, the acquirer is the United States, a state, or D.C., or the interest is in a publicly traded partnership or trust | No amount to withhold; government acquirer; publicly traded interest | IRS exceptions page |
Two kill-switches sit under the table. Under § 1445(b)(7), an affidavit does not protect the buyer if the buyer — or the qualified substitute — has actual knowledge it is false, or receives an agent's notice that it is false. A certification the buyer must send to the IRS is ineffective if never sent. The affidavit can also go to a qualified substitute — the attorney or title company running the closing, or the transferee's agent — who gives the buyer a statement under penalty of perjury that it holds the affidavit.
The $300,000 residence exception has a use test, not just a price test
The residence exception is the one buyers most often misread. The price cap is only half of it: the buyer must be an individual acquiring the property for use as a residence, and the buyer or a family member must have definite plans to reside there for at least 50 percent of the days the property is used by any person during each of the first two 12-month periods after the transfer. Vacant days do not count. A $280,000 home purchase withholds nothing; at $320,000 it withholds $48,000; a $280,000 rental withholds the full 15 percent — the use fails even though the price passes.
Joint owners and grantor trusts: split the amount realized first
Where a foreign person and at least one other person own the property together, the amount realized is allocated by each transferor's capital contribution — not by title percentages, and not by who signed the contract. The IRS's FAQ answers it directly: a husband and wife are treated as having contributed 50 percent each, so on an $800,000 sale with a foreign spouse, the buyer withholds on the foreign spouse's $400,000 share — $60,000 — and the U.S. spouse's share withholds nothing. The foreign transferors must agree how the withholding credit is allocated and tell the transferee by the 10th day after the transfer; without agreement, the transferee credits it evenly. The same look-through applies to grantor trusts: withholding reaches the foreign grantor's portion of a USRPI in a trust under IRC §§ 671–678.
The 20-day clock: Forms 8288, 8288-A, and 8288-B
The money must reach the IRS on a deadline the buyer cannot extend. The transferee files Form 8288, the U.S. Withholding Tax Return for Dispositions by Foreign Persons of U.S. Real Property Interests, by the 20th day after the disposition. A transfer on November 18 is due December 8. For each person withheld from, the transferee prepares a Form 8288-A, attaches copies A and B to the Form 8288, and keeps copy C. The IRS stamps copy B and sends it to the transferor, who attaches it to the U.S. return to claim the withholding credit. Both TINs must appear; a seller without one needs an ITIN on Form W-7.
The escape valve is Form 8288-B, the Application for Withholding Certificate. Either party can apply, before or on the disposition date, for a certificate that excuses withholding or reduces it to the transferor's maximum tax liability — the cap § 1445(c)(1) sets, with a refund of any excess withheld. If the application is still pending at closing, the full amount must still be withheld, but it need not be reported and paid immediately: it is reported and paid within 20 days after the IRS mails the certificate or the notice of denial. On the worked example, an 8288-B would have cut the withholding from $202,500 to $90,000, keeping $112,500 with the seller at closing. Filing to buy time backfires: if the principal purpose is delay, interest and penalties run from the 21st day after the transfer until payment. All FIRPTA documents go to the IRS Center in Ogden, Utah — P.O. Box 409101, Ogden, UT 84409.
Distributions: the 21 percent corporate rule
FIRPTA does not stop at sales. A foreign corporation distributing a U.S. real property interest must withhold 21 percent of the gain it recognizes to its foreign shareholders — the current § 11(b) rate, on the gain rather than the price. On a $2,000,000 gain that is $420,000. A domestic corporation distributing property to a foreign shareholder in redemption or liquidation must withhold 15 percent of fair market value, where the shareholder's interest is itself a USRPI. Whoever controls the disposition is the withholding agent, and the rate follows the form of the transaction.
Execution checklist: the closing-table sequence
- [x] Step 1 — Ask the foreign-person question at the offer, not at closing: is any transferor foreign, including through a grantor trust or foreign-owned entity? Get it in writing before signing.
- [x] Step 2 — Compute the amount realized the IRS way: cash (principal only) plus other property at fair market value plus every liability the buyer assumes. Run the tax estimator on the gross figure, not on the gain.
- [x] Step 3 — Test the exceptions before the money moves: nonforeign affidavit with TIN, $300,000 residence with the 50-percent use plan, publicly traded stock, or a USRPHC certification within 30 days.
- [x] Step 4 — File Form 8288-B early if the tax is below the withholding: apply before or on the disposition date; the certificate or denial sets the 20-day payment clock.
- [x] Step 5 — Withhold 15 percent at closing if no exception applies: hold it in escrow, separate from the purchase funds, so it cannot be spent before Form 8288 is filed.
- [x] Step 6 — Calendar the 20th day after transfer: Form 8288 with payment, 8288-A copies A and B attached, copy C kept, both TINs on the forms, mailed to Ogden, UT 84409.
- [x] Step 7 — Split joint ownership by capital contribution: spouses 50/50; get the foreign transferors' credit-allocation agreement by the 10th day.
- [x] Step 8 — Send the stamped copy B to the seller: the seller attaches it to the U.S. return to claim the withholding credit; without it, the refund waits.
- [x] Step 9 — File the nonrecognition notice if the transfer is tax-free: a copy by the 20th day after transfer, meeting all five requirements of Treas. Reg. § 1.1445-2(d)(2)(iii).
- [x] Step 10 — Keep the affidavit file: affidavits, certifications, and the substitute's statement stay with the closing file — an affidavit the buyer cannot produce never existed.
Who should not rely on this playbook
This playbook is for buyers, sellers, settlement officers, and advisers on a U.S. real property sale involving a foreign person. It does not cover the seller's own return — the 1040-NR filing, the § 897 gain computation, and the home-country foreign tax credit. It does not help a buyer who already closed without withholding; that is a disclosure and penalty-abatement conversation with a CPA. It is not a substitute for counsel where the seller is a foreign corporation distributing property, a REIT, or a publicly traded partnership — those run through § 1445(e) and Forms 1042/1042-S. The closing documents that touch this playbook are the Form 1099-S real estate closing playbook, which records the sale, the § 367(d) IP transfer playbook for cross-border IP transfers, and the Form 5472 foreign-owned LLC playbook for foreign-owned LLC reporting.
