A non-resident founder forming a U.S. company buys three things, and the three vendors here sell them in three shapes: Doola as an annual subscription bundling formation, EIN, agent, and address; Firstbase as a cheap one-time formation with everything after it charged separately; Stripe Atlas as a single flat fee including the state filing and the first year of agent service. The headline prices — $297, $99, $500 — cannot be compared directly, because they include different things. This guide prices all three on one baseline, from the vendors' own pricing pages read November 16, 2026: a Delaware C-Corp, one-page certificate, no expedite, no add-ons beyond what the route requires.
What each price actually includes
| Included | Doola Starter ($297/yr) | Firstbase Start ($99 offer / $399 list, one-time) | Stripe Atlas ($500 one-time) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Formation filings | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| EIN (expedited) | Yes (no expedite) | Yes, expedited | Yes |
| Operating agreement / bylaws | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Registered agent service | Yes | No — $299/yr add-on, required | Yes, year 1; $100/yr after |
| Virtual mailing / business address | Yes | Mailroom $35/mo or $315/yr | No |
| Bank account | Via Mercury partner | Via banking partners | Stripe Treasury |
| Free dissolution | No | Not stated | Not stated |
| Annual state report filing | No | Reminders only | No |
| Tax filing | No ($1,999/yr plan) | No ($1,799/yr add-on) | No |
| Bookkeeping | No ($300/yr Pulse) | No ($1,890/yr add-on) | No |
| Entity types | LLC or C-Corp | Delaware / Wyoming | Delaware C-Corp + LLCs |
| Formation speed | 1–2 business days | Not stated | 1 business day |
Doola's own comparison table is explicit: Starter includes formation filings, the EIN, the operating agreement, the registered agent, and the virtual mailing address, with email support; expedited EIN, free dissolution, the annual state report filing, tax consultation, and business IRS tax filings are marked no on Starter. Firstbase's Start page is equally explicit the other way: the registered agent is a $299-a-year add-on, required for incorporation — the $99 does not include it. Atlas's page states the $500 includes Delaware filing fees and the first year of agent service; the agent is $100 a year after.
The Delaware state fee
Every total below uses the Delaware Division of Corporations fee schedule revised August 1, 2026: a certificate of incorporation costs a $109 minimum, plus $9 for each page beyond the first; an LLC certificate of formation costs $110. A Delaware C-Corp then owes a $50 annual report and franchise tax — $175 minimum under the Authorized Shares Method — due March 1, with a $200 late penalty plus 1.5% monthly interest. The Division's own site rejects automated reads from this network, so these figures rest on the published August 1, 2026 schedule as corroborated across independent November 2026 reads — confirm the live schedule before paying. The older $89 incorporation fee in many guides is the pre-August-2026 schedule and is now wrong — our Delaware franchise-tax guide carries the current $175 minimum and March 1 deadline, and our Atlas vs Clerky vs Northwest guide prices Atlas against two other services.
Year-one math
The state filing fee is $109 for a one-page Delaware certificate of incorporation — the same for all three vendors; what differs is who pays it and what is bundled.
| Route | Platform fee | State fee | Agent year 1 | Year-1 total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doola Starter | $297 | $109 | Included | $406 |
| Firstbase Start (offer) | $99 | $109 | $299 | $507 |
| Firstbase Start (list) | $399 | $109 | $299 | $807 |
| Stripe Atlas | $500 (incl. state fee) | $0 extra | Included | $500 |
Firstbase's $99 is an offer — the page shows $99 against a $399 list price with the line "Formation is on us. Pay only your state fee." The guide prices both — $99 today, $399 if the offer ends. At the offer price Firstbase is $7 more than Atlas in year one and $101 more than Doola; at list, $307 more than Atlas and $401 more than Doola. The $99 headline is the cheapest number on any of the three pages and the most expensive route once the agent is added. Founders paying from abroad should convert the year-one total into their home currency with our Multi-Currency Exchange Rate Converter before judging whether the $94 gap between Doola and Atlas matters.
Year-two math
Year two is where the shapes diverge. Doola renews at $297 a year, agent included. Firstbase has no annual platform fee — Start is one-time — but the agent renews at $299. Atlas has no annual platform fee either; its agent drops to $100. All three owe the same $225 in state costs: $50 annual report plus $175 minimum franchise tax.
| Route | Platform renewal | Agent year 2 | State costs | Year-2 total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doola Starter | $297 | Included | $225 | $522 |
| Firstbase Start | $0 | $299 | $225 | $524 |
| Stripe Atlas | $0 | $100 | $225 | $325 |
| Route | Year 1 | Year 2 | Two-year total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe Atlas | $500 | $325 | $825 |
| Doola Starter | $406 | $522 | $928 |
| Firstbase Start (offer) | $507 | $524 | $1,031 |
| Firstbase Start (list) | $807 | $524 | $1,331 |
Atlas wins the two-year race by $103 over Doola and $206 over Firstbase at the offer price — $506 at list. The margin comes entirely from the agent: $100 a year against Doola's bundled $297 subscription and Firstbase's $299 standalone agent. Run it forward: Atlas costs $325 a year from year two on, Doola $522, Firstbase $524, so the Atlas lead grows about $197 a year against Doola and $199 against Firstbase — already cheapest by the end of year two, and widening every year after.
What Atlas does not sell
The two-year totals above buy formation and compliance only. A company that needs books kept and taxes filed must buy those separately; Atlas has no product at all. Doola Tax and Compliance is $1,999 a year plus state fees — everything in Starter plus federal and state tax filing and a 1:1 tax consultation. Firstbase Tax Filing is $1,799 a year, covering state and federal taxes for LLCs and C-Corps, including Form 5472 for non-U.S.-owned single-member LLCs. The gap is $200 a year:
At full back-office level, Doola Business-in-a-Box is $2,999 a year ($329 a month) and Firstbase One is $199 a month billed yearly at $2,388 — a $611-a-year gap:
An Atlas founder who needs tax filing hires a CPA, whose fee is outside every total in this guide. That is not a mark against Atlas — its $500 is the cheapest way to exist as a company — but a founder who prices only formation and forgets the first tax return has underpriced the first year by at least $1,799.
Bank account, EIN, and the non-resident reality
None of the three vendors is a bank, and none can guarantee an account. Doola applies for a Mercury business account — Mercury is a fintech, not a bank, with services through Choice Financial Group and Column N.A., Members FDIC — and asks for an international passport for each founder or majority owner. Firstbase opens an account with one of its banking partners as part of Start. Atlas uses Stripe Treasury and pays $500 when the founder opens the Treasury account within 7 days of incorporating, plus $2,500 in Stripe credits and $200,000-plus in partner offers.
The EIN follows the same pattern: Doola obtains it as part of Starter (expedited EIN is a higher-plan feature), Firstbase lists expedited EIN setup in Start, and Atlas obtains the tax ID as part of the $500. No Social Security number is required — the company applies on Form SS-4 — and a founder who needs an ITIN applies on Form W-7. Doola reports 32,000-plus businesses across 175-plus countries; Firstbase 30,000-plus across 190-plus countries and $350,000-plus in deals and rewards; Atlas 120,000-plus companies and 1 in 4 new Delaware corporations. Scale is a tiebreaker, not a decision.
Atlas's edge for venture-backed founders is not price but paper: it issues founder equity, obtains the tax ID, and automatically submits the 83(b) election at no additional cost, with Cooley-designed documents. A founder planning a priced round wants the 83(b) filed on time and the cap table clean from day one; that is the Atlas buyer. Doola's edge is the back office — bookkeeping at $300 a year on Pulse, taxes at $1,999, a dedicated account manager on Business-in-a-Box. Firstbase's edge is modularity: the cheapest entry at $99, with every later need — mailroom, agent, accounting, tax filing, sales tax — a separate add-on. Our LegalZoom vs Bizee vs Northwest guide prices the older generalist formation services on the same state baseline.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
The decision matrix
| Founder profile | Best route | Why | Two-year cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Venture-backed Delaware C-Corp, raising soon | Stripe Atlas | 83(b) + founder equity + Cooley documents; cheapest two-year total | $825 |
| Solo non-resident, one vendor for books and taxes | Doola Starter, then Tax and Compliance | Agent and address included; $1,999/yr tax filing; Mercury path | $928 formation; $1,999/yr taxes |
| Cash-tight founder, self-manages compliance | Firstbase Start at the $99 offer | Lowest entry price; add agent, mailroom, and tax filing only as needed | $1,031 (offer) |
| Founder who needs a Wyoming entity | Firstbase Start | Only vendor of the three offering Wyoming formation | $1,031 (offer) |
| Founder who will not file taxes themselves | Doola or Firstbase, never Atlas alone | Atlas sells no tax filing; budget $1,799–$1,999/yr | Add $1,799–$1,999/yr |
Buying checklist
- [x] Step 1 — Pick the entity: Delaware C-Corp for a venture path, LLC for a single-owner operating business; confirm the state fee — $109 C-Corp, $110 LLC — before comparing vendor totals.
- [x] Step 2 — Price the agent: confirm whether the registered agent is included, for how many years, and at what renewal — $100 (Atlas), in $297 (Doola), $299 (Firstbase).
- [x] Step 3 — Price year two: add the $50 annual report and $175 minimum franchise tax to every route; the cheapest year one is rarely the cheapest year two.
- [x] Step 4 — Price the tax return: if the vendor does not sell tax filing, get a CPA quote before incorporating — $1,799 (Firstbase) to $1,999 (Doola) a year is the benchmark.
- [x] Step 5 — Confirm the bank path: passport ready; Mercury (Doola), banking partners (Firstbase), or Stripe Treasury (Atlas, plus $500 within 7 days); approval is the bank's decision.
- [x] Step 6 — Calendar the recurring duties: March 1 annual report and franchise tax; Form 5472 for a foreign-owned single-member LLC ($25,000 penalty); FinCEN beneficial-ownership reporting.
- [x] Step 7 — Re-check the offer price: Firstbase Start at $99 is an offer against a $399 list; verify the live price before paying, and re-run the year-one total if the offer has ended.
When the ranking changes
The ranking holds on the stated baseline and breaks in three cases. First, if the Firstbase $99 offer ends, Firstbase falls to last, $403 behind Atlas over two years — re-check the offer before buying. Second, if the founder forms an LLC rather than a C-Corp, the state fee becomes $110 and the Form 5472 duty appears for a foreign-owned single-member LLC, which can add $1,799 a year in tax filing to any route without it. Third, if the founder needs bookkeeping and tax filing, Atlas drops out entirely and the choice is Doola at $2,999 a year against Firstbase One at $2,388 — a $611 gap in Firstbase's favour. Price the company you will run for two years, not the one you incorporate on day one.

