Buy Now, Pay Later Merchant Fees: Klarna vs Affirm vs Afterpay — The Merchant Playbook
A customer who picks buy now, pay later at checkout pays nothing extra if the payments land on time. The merchant pays instead. On a standard pay-in-four sale, the provider takes roughly six cents of every dollar plus thirty cents per order — about twice the cost of a domestic card sale, charged on every BNPL order whether or not the customer ever misses a payment.
BNPL is a short loan made at the point of sale: the customer takes the goods at once and repays in instalments, most often four payments over six weeks. The provider underwrites the customer, pays the merchant the full order value minus its fee, and collects from the customer. If the customer stops paying, the loss sits with the provider.
What the merchant actually pays
Every provider charges a merchant discount rate, the MDR, plus a fixed per-transaction fee. None of the three providers here charges a monthly, setup or integration fee, so the per-sale fee is the whole cost story — and only some rates are published.
Klarna publishes no merchant rate card of its own for the United States; its developer documentation states the rate is returned per transaction through its Price Plans API, so the rate is set in each merchant's agreement. The rate merchants actually meet is visible through Stripe, which resells Klarna at 5.99 percent plus 30 cents per successful transaction. Longer-term Klarna financing, where the customer pays interest over up to 36 months, carries a lower merchant rate of 3.29 percent plus 30 cents.
Affirm also publishes no merchant rate. Its merchant FAQ says merchants pay a merchant discount rate and a transaction fee, set by program, business size, and risk profile. Stripe lists the market rate: 6 percent plus 30 cents standard, 7.99 percent plus 30 cents enhanced. Affirm's filings explain the gap: fees run larger on 0 percent APR financing.
Afterpay, now Cash App Afterpay in the United States, sits in the same band. Square, which owns Afterpay through Block, publishes the rate plainly: 6 percent plus 30 cents per transaction, fixed across its in-person and online products, with no monthly fee and no startup cost. Afterpay's merchant terms prohibit surcharging.
For scale, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's study of five large providers found merchant fees averaged 2.49 percent of the volume financed in 2021, down from 2.91 percent in 2020.
The decision table
| Provider | Pay-in-four fee | Longer-term financing | Late fee | Settlement | Fee refunded on return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Klarna | 5.99% + $0.30 (Stripe) | 3.29% + $0.30, up to 36 mo | Up to $7 per missed payment | Up front, less fee | No |
| Affirm | 6.00% + $0.30 std; 7.99% + $0.30 enhanced (Stripe) | Quote-based; higher on 0% APR | $0, ever | ACH, 1–3 days | No |
| Afterpay | 6.00% + $0.30 (Square); 4–6% neg. | Pay Monthly, up to 12 mo | Capped at 25% of order | 1–3 days | No |
| Card | 2.90% + $0.30 (Stripe) | — | — | 1–2 days | Usually kept |
Two rows decide most choices: BNPL costs roughly double the card rate, and all three providers keep the fee when an order is returned.
Follow one sale through the rails: the customer authorises at the POS, the provider underwrites the plan, and settlement reaches the merchant by ACH or Wire within three days, less the MDR. Cross-border orders add FX and SWIFT routing, and the provider runs KYC and AML checks plus 3DS authentication first.
Per-sale net math, worked at four order values
The math below is editorial derivation from the published rates above.
| Order | Klarna 5.99% + $0.30 | Affirm standard 6.00% + $0.30 | Affirm enhanced 7.99% + $0.30 | Card 2.90% + $0.30 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | Keeps $93.71 | Keeps $93.70 | Keeps $91.71 | Keeps $96.80 |
| $250 | Keeps $234.72 | Keeps $234.70 | Keeps $229.72 | Keeps $242.45 |
| $500 | Keeps $469.75 | Keeps $469.70 | Keeps $459.75 | Keeps $485.20 |
| $1,000 | Keeps $939.80 | Keeps $939.70 | Keeps $919.80 | Keeps $970.70 |
The BNPL premium over the card at Klarna's rate is 3.09 dollars on a 100-dollar order, 7.73 dollars on a 250-dollar order, 15.45 dollars on a 500-dollar order, and 30.90 dollars on a 1,000-dollar order; on Affirm enhanced it runs 5.09, 12.73, 25.45 and 50.90 dollars.
The break-even test
BNPL earns its fee when customers who would have abandoned the checkout complete the purchase, and when customers buy a larger basket.
Take a 250-dollar average order at a 40 percent gross margin: gross profit per order is 100 dollars, and the extra fee of 7.73 dollars needs a 7.73 percent lift. At a 20 percent margin it needs a 15.46 percent lift; at a 10 percent margin it needs a 30.92 percent lift. Test it as a checkout experiment: offer BNPL to half of checkout traffic for four weeks, hold it back from the other half, and compare completed-order rate, average order value, and gross profit per visitor.
Returns, refunds and the fee that never comes back
All three providers keep the merchant fee when a customer returns goods. Affirm states it plainly in its merchant FAQ; Afterpay's and Klarna's merchant terms say the same. The merchant refunds the full order value and absorbs the fee as a loss on a sale that no longer exists.
Work the loss at a 250-dollar order on Klarna's rate. The merchant receives 234.72 dollars at sale, refunds 250 dollars on return, and ends 15.28 dollars down. On Affirm enhanced the loss is 20.28 dollars; on a card sale it is 7.55 dollars.
The effect compounds with the return rate. Take 100 orders at 250 dollars on Klarna's rate: 25,000 dollars of volume and 1,527.50 dollars of fees. If 10 orders are returned in full, the merchant refunds 2,500 dollars, keeps 22,500 dollars of revenue, and still pays 1,527.50 dollars in fees — an effective fee of 6.79 percent on revenue kept, not 5.99 percent.
Chargebacks and disputes: who carries what
The provider absorbs consumer nonpayment: once it approves the customer and pays the merchant, a customer who simply stops paying is the provider's problem. What it does not absorb is the merchant's own failure — goods not received, goods not as described, fraud on the merchant's side, or an unauthorised transaction. Those disputes still land on the merchant, through the provider's dispute process rather than the card network's chargeback process. Keep the same evidence pack as for card orders: proof of delivery and the checkout product description.
The regulatory position moved twice in a year. In May 2024 the Bureau issued an interpretive rule (89 FR 47068, effective July 30, 2024) treating BNPL digital user accounts as credit cards under Regulation Z, which would have made the lenders card issuers owing consumers periodic statements, billing-error investigation, and refund protections. In May 2025 the Bureau withdrew that rule (90 FR 20084, May 12, 2025) and said it would not prioritise enforcement of the withdrawn guidance.
Late fees: the customer's cost that becomes the merchant's problem
Late fees are charged to the customer, not the merchant, but they shape whether customers keep using the merchant's checkout. Klarna charges up to 7 dollars per missed payment on Pay in 4. Afterpay caps late fees at 25 percent of the order value. Affirm charges no late fees at all, ever, and states so in its merchant FAQ. The Bureau's December 2025 market report found late fees were charged on 4.1 percent of loans in 2023. A customer stung by a late fee blames the checkout, not the lender.
Licensing and compliance exposure
There is no federal BNPL licence; licensing is decided state by state. The merchant does not lend the money and needs no lending licence, but does need a provider licensed where the merchant's customers live.
In March 2020 California's regulator, now the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, concluded that a major pay-in-four provider's plans were unlicensed loans. The provider agreed to lend to Californians only through a licensed affiliate and to refund 905,000 dollars of fees collected from more than 640,000 Californians. That law requires a licence for any business making consumer or commercial loans, with a 25,000-dollar minimum net worth and a 25,000-dollar surety bond.
New York wrote a dedicated BNPL law: the Buy Now Pay Later Act, enacted May 9, 2025, requires providers to obtain a licence or authorisation. The Department of Financial Services published implementing regulations for comment in July 2026; the comment period closed on September 14, 2026, with the rules not yet in effect.
Short-term BNPL loans sit in a gap in the Truth in Lending Act: a loan repayable in four or fewer instalments without a finance charge falls outside the Act's definition of a creditor. The Bureau's 2024 interpretive rule tried to close that gap; its 2025 withdrawal reopened it.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
Who should NOT offer BNPL
A merchant with gross margins below 15 percent should not offer BNPL at standard rates: the fee consumes too much profit per order for any plausible conversion lift to repay it. A merchant with return rates above 25 percent should not offer it either, because the non-refunded fee turns every return into a double loss. A merchant selling goods under 30 dollars should think twice, because the 30-cent fixed fee is a full percentage point or more on a small basket. A merchant in a restricted category should check eligibility before integration work starts. A merchant whose customers are mostly over 55 should test demand first: BNPL's heaviest users are younger shoppers buying fashion, electronics and furniture.
Execution checklist
- Pull the merchant's average order value, gross margin and return rate from the last 90 days.
- Run the per-sale net math and the break-even formula at the merchant's own order values and margin.
- Get the merchant fee in writing from each provider.
- Confirm in writing that the provider holds, or lends through an affiliate holding, a California Financing Law licence.
- Read the provider's refund clause and dispute section, and confirm the fee is not refunded on returns.
- Check the provider's restricted-industry list against the merchant's own catalogue before integration work starts.
- Run a four-week split test, or one month on and one month off, comparing order rate and gross profit per visitor.
- Add the provider's late-fee rule to the merchant's own FAQ page.
- Review monthly: BNPL share of orders, return-adjusted effective fee, and gross profit per visitor. Switch it off if the effective fee exceeds break-even for two consecutive months.
Frequently asked questions
How much do Klarna, Affirm and Afterpay charge merchants? At standard published rates: Klarna 5.99 percent plus 30 cents, Affirm 6 percent plus 30 cents standard and 7.99 percent plus 30 cents enhanced, Afterpay 6 percent plus 30 cents.
Does the merchant get the BNPL fee back on a return? No — all three keep the merchant discount rate and the transaction fee on refunded orders. On a 250-dollar order at Klarna's rate, a full return costs 15.28 dollars in kept fees.
How fast does a merchant get paid? Up front, in full, less the fee — Affirm by ACH and Afterpay within one to three business days.
Who carries the loss if the customer stops paying? The provider does: it underwrites each transaction and absorbs consumer nonpayment. The merchant still carries disputes about goods not received and goods not as described.
Does a merchant need a lending licence to offer BNPL? No — the merchant does not lend the money, so the provider needs the licence. In California, providers must hold a California Financing Law licence or lend through a licensed affiliate.
Is BNPL regulated like a credit card? Not under a settled federal rule. The Bureau's May 2024 interpretive rule treated BNPL digital accounts as credit cards under Regulation Z, but the Bureau withdrew it in May 2025.
Sources
- CFPB interpretive rule, Truth in Lending (Regulation Z): digital user accounts and BNPL loans, 89 FR 47068, May 31, 2024.
- CFPB, withdrawal of interpretive rules and guidance, 90 FR 20084, May 12, 2025.
- CFPB, Buy Now, Pay Later market reports, September 2022 and December 2025.
- Stripe, local payment methods pricing.
- Square, pricing and fees pages (Block, Inc.).
- Affirm Business Hub, merchant FAQ.
- Affirm investor disclosures, FY2026.
- Klarna developer documentation, Price Plans API.
- California DFPI, California Financing Law licensing.
- New York Buy Now Pay Later Act, May 9, 2025.
For the card-processing comparison behind these numbers, see Stripe vs Square vs PayPal: payment processing fees compared, the consumer-side picture in PayPal vs Venmo vs Cash App: payment app fees compared, and the reserve rules in Merchant account reserve holdbacks: the release playbook. Before switching BNPL on, run the merchant's numbers through the profit calculator with the BNPL fee as a cost per order.
