Form 8283 is the form that decides whether a noncash gift to charity is a deduction or a donation with no tax benefit at all. The IRS does not ask for it on every gift. It asks for it the moment the numbers get large enough to fake, and the statute behind it, 26 U.S.C. § 170(f)(11), denies the entire deduction when the paperwork is wrong — not a percentage of it, the whole thing.
The form itself is short. The trap is that it is an appraisal summary, not an appraisal. The IRS says so in the instructions for Form 8283 (revised December 2025): a separate, qualified appraisal is required for any gift of property valued at more than $5,000, and Form 8283 is the summary of that appraisal. Filing the summary without the appraisal behind it is the same as filing nothing.
The threshold ladder: what each dollar figure triggers
Every noncash gift sits somewhere on this ladder. The thresholds aggregate similar items of property donated to one or more donees — § 170(f)(11)(F) treats them as one property — so five $1,200 paintings to the same museum are a $6,000 gift for threshold purposes, not five small ones.
| Threshold | What it triggers | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| $250 or more, any gift | Contemporaneous written acknowledgment from the donee, obtained before the return is filed | 26 U.S.C. § 170(f)(8) |
| More than $500 | Form 8283 must be filed; property description under § 170(f)(11)(B) | 26 U.S.C. § 170(f)(11)(A)(i) |
| More than $5,000 | Section B plus a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser | 26 U.S.C. § 170(f)(11)(C)–(D) |
| More than $500,000 | The complete signed qualified appraisal (PDF) must be attached to the return | IRS Publication 561; Form 8283 instructions |
| Vehicle over $500 | Donee acknowledgment on Form 1098-C terms; deduction capped at gross sale proceeds if the donee sells without significant intervening use | 26 U.S.C. § 170(f)(12) |
| Art $20,000 or more per object | Complete copy of the signed appraisal attached; photograph provided on request | IRS Publication 561; Form 8283 instructions |
The $250 acknowledgment rule is the one donors skip most often. The acknowledgment must state the amount of cash and a description — not the value — of any property contributed, whether the donee provided goods or services in return, and a good-faith estimate of the value of anything it did provide. A thank-you letter that omits the goods-or-services statement fails the test, and the acknowledgment must be in hand before the return is filed.
The $500 trigger has a carve-out worth knowing. § 170(f)(11)(A)(ii) excepts readily valued property from the appraisal-summary and appraiser-declaration requirements: cash, publicly traded securities, and qualified vehicles with the § 170(f)(12) acknowledgment. A $50,000 gift of listed stock still goes on Form 8283, but it does not need a qualified appraisal, because the market prices it every trading day.
Section A versus Section B: which half you complete
Form 8283 has two sections, and the dollar figure picks the section, not the donor.
Section A covers property with a claimed deduction of $5,000 or less, plus publicly traded securities regardless of amount. It asks for the donee and its EIN, the date and manner of acquisition, the cost or other basis, and the fair market value (FMV) claimed.
Section B covers everything over $5,000 that is not excepted. It adds the appraisal summary, the appraiser's declaration in Part IV, and the donee's acknowledgment in Part V. You file a separate Section B for each donee organization and each item of property, or group of similar items. Three paintings to three museums means three Section Bs.
Part V, the donee acknowledgment, is where filings stall. The donee organization must complete it for a contributing partnership or S corporation. For an individual donor the donee's signature is requested but the deduction is not disallowed solely because the signature could not be obtained — provided you attach a detailed explanation of why. Attach the explanation, name the person you asked, and date the request.
The § 170(f)(11) machine: appraisal, appraiser, and timing
The statute builds the substantiation in three layers, and each layer has its own definition.
Layer one — the description. For any deduction over $500, the return must include a description of the property and any other information the Secretary requires. This is § 170(f)(11)(B), and it does not apply to a C corporation that is not a personal service corporation.
Layer two — the appraisal summary. For deductions over $5,000, § 170(f)(11)(C) requires an appraisal summary that meets the regulatory requirements: the appraiser's qualifications, the valuation method, the date of the appraisal, and the appraiser's signature. The summary travels with the return as Section B.
Layer three — the appraisal itself. § 170(f)(11)(E) defines a qualified appraisal as one conducted under generally accepted appraisal standards by a qualified appraiser: an individual with an appraisal designation from a recognized professional appraiser organization or equivalent education and experience, who regularly performs appraisals for compensation, and who demonstrates verifiable experience valuing that type of property. The statute disqualifies anyone prohibited from practicing before the IRS under 31 U.S.C. § 330(c) at any time during the three years ending on the appraisal date. Your CPA is not automatically a qualified appraiser for a painting; your art dealer is not automatically one for a patent.
Timing is a hard rule, and it is measured in days, not in tax years. Publication 561 states the appraisal must be dated no earlier than 60 days before the contribution and no later than the due date, including extensions, of the return on which the deduction is first claimed. An appraisal written 90 days before the gift is stale; one written after the extended due date is late. Both cost the deduction.
Founder & CEO Insight — Enow A. Jovial
The math: three worked examples with the deduction at stake
Example 1: the painting with the wrong use
A founder donates a painting to a local museum. FMV is $6,000. Her basis is $2,000. The museum will hang it in its permanent collection — a use related to its exempt purpose. Because the use is related and the property is long-term capital gain property, the deduction is the full FMV:
Now change one fact: the museum auctions the painting at its annual gala instead. The use is now unrelated to its exempt purpose, and § 170(e)(1)(B)(i) reduces the contribution by the gain that would have been long-term capital gain:
The same painting, the same museum, the same $6,000 appraisal — and the deduction falls by $4,000 because of what the donee does with it. Ask the donee, in writing, what it will do with the property before you donate it. The answer belongs in the appraisal file.
Example 2: the car and the gross-proceeds cap
A founder donates a car with a claimed value of $8,000. The donee sells it at auction two weeks later for $5,200, with no significant intervening use and no material improvement. § 170(f)(12)(A)(ii) caps the deduction at the gross proceeds:
The $2,800 gap is not a rounding error. It is the difference between a valuation and a market. The donee must give the donor a contemporaneous written acknowledgment that meets § 170(f)(12)(B), and the acknowledgment travels with the return.
Example 3: the AGI limit and the five-year carryover
A founder with a contribution base of $200,000 donates capital gain property to a private foundation. The § 170(b)(1)(B) limit for capital gain property to a private foundation is 30% of the contribution base:
She donates property worth $100,000. She deducts $60,000 this year. The remaining $40,000 is not lost — § 170(d)(1) treats it as a contribution paid in each of the five succeeding tax years, in order, subject to the same percentage limit in each of those years. Cash to a public charity is different: § 170(b)(1)(G) allows up to 60% of the contribution base for cash gifts, with the same five-year carryover. The form does not do this math for you. Schedule A carries the current-year figure; the carryover lives on your own workpapers, and Form 8283 is where the property behind it is documented.
The economics of the appraisal itself deserve a line of arithmetic. A qualified appraisal for a $40,000 equipment gift typically costs $1,500 to $3,000. At a 24% marginal rate, the $40,000 deduction is worth $9,600 in tax. The appraisal is 16% to 31% of the benefit — expensive, but skipping it costs 100% of the benefit, because the deduction is denied in full.
What reduces the deduction before the form ever matters
Section 170(e) cuts the deduction before the thresholds are reached. Ordinary income property — inventory, a work created by the donor, property held one year or less — is deductible only at basis, because § 170(e)(1)(A) subtracts the gain that would not have been long-term capital gain. Tangible personal property put to an unrelated use is reduced the same way, as Example 1 shows. An LLC, an S-Corp, and a C-Corp all file the same Form 8283, but the deduction each one claims for the same box of goods can differ by thousands of dollars.
Clothing and household items carry their own trap. The instructions require Section B for a single article of clothing or a household item that is not in good used condition or better, even when the claimed value is far below $5,000. A bag of worn clothing with a $400 claimed value needs no form. A single damaged designer coat claimed at $600 needs Section B and a qualified appraisal. The condition of the item, not the price tag, decides.
Who should not use this playbook, and what to do instead
This playbook is for donors claiming a noncash deduction above $500 on a filed return — founders donating equipment, art, vehicles, or securities, and the CPAs who prepare their returns. It is not a valuation guide: it does not tell you what a painting is worth, and no article can. If the property is a conservation easement, a fractional interest in art, or IP, the rules in § 170(f)(3), § 170(o), and § 170(m) add layers this guide does not cover. If the gift is to a foreign charity or a private foundation you control, the acknowledgment and related-party rules change the analysis. In each of those cases the right move is a CPA or a tax attorney before the gift, not a form after it.
For the donor-advised fund version of this decision — where the deduction lands in the contribution year and the grant happens later — our donor-advised fund playbook works the timing and the Form 8283 interaction. For the Schedule A mechanics the form feeds into, the Schedule A itemized deductions playbook carries the full line-by-line sequence. To check the tax value of the deduction before you commit to an appraisal, run the numbers in our tax estimator.
Filing checklist
- Value the property before the gift. Commission the qualified appraisal inside the 60-day window before the contribution date, from an appraiser with verifiable experience in that property type.
- Confirm the donee's intended use in writing. Related use preserves FMV; unrelated use reduces the deduction to basis under § 170(e)(1)(B)(i).
- Get the contemporaneous written acknowledgment. For any gift of $250 or more, the acknowledgment must reach you before the return is filed.
- Complete the right section. Section A at $5,000 or less; Section B above $5,000, one per donee and per item or group of similar items.
- Collect the donee's Part V signature. If it cannot be obtained, attach a detailed written explanation naming who you asked and when.
- Attach the full appraisal when required. Over $500,000, the complete signed appraisal goes with the return; for art at $20,000 or more per object, attach the appraisal and keep a photograph ready.
- Track the carryover. Any amount above the 30%, 50%, or 60% AGI limit carries forward five years under § 170(d)(1); record it on your workpapers, not just on the form.
- [x] Appraisal dated within 60 days before the gift and before the extended return due date
- [x] Acknowledgment in hand before the return is filed, with the goods-or-services statement
- [x] Section B filed per donee and per item above $5,000, with the appraiser's Part IV declaration
- [x] Vehicle acknowledgment and gross-proceeds check completed before claiming the value
- [x] AGI limit applied and the excess carryover recorded for the next five years
